The Furry Forums would like to place cookies on your computer to help us make this website better. To find out more about the cookies, see our privacy notice.
To accept the cookie click here, or please login or register.

Author Topic: Writing sample  (Read 1125 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Xavier Akafur

  • Boisterous Bear
  • **
  • awards This user has been a forum member for over 10 years
  • Posts: 142
  • Gender: Male
    • Awards
  • Species: Otter-Wolf
  • Coloring: Chocolate brown, tan
  • Height: 6'0"
  • Weight: 205 lbs
  • Build: Sturdy
Writing sample
« on: August 09, 2010, 08:34:31 AM »
Yo, aspiring fantasy writer here. Just wanting some feedback on my writing style. Just gonna write a snippet, and you fellas can tell me whatcha think.

Rebel turned at the sound of cracking limbs, the massive man's entire body tensing as he saw the creature that came lumbering from the treeline. In an instant, his massive sword was in his hands the chipped and battle-worn blade a welcome barrier between him and this new adversary. The creature halted, giving the human a good look at it's insect-like body. The creature was one not native to his world, that was for certain. It stood on six spindly legs, each one curling to a sharpened point, all of which were currently embedded in the earth to support the bug's weight. It's body was like that of a beetle standing upright, a mix of mottled brown and black chitin covering it's entirely. Where the plates of that natural armor ended, wicked spines sprouted from it's body. Two limbs were poised in front of the creature, each tipped with three long, blade-like fingers. Four beady eyes stared back at the man, expressionless and black as night. A blunt horn crested the creature's head, which now slowly lowered to aim at the man who stood in its way. The plates on the creatures back opened up with a high-pitched buzzing.

Rebel did not pause to think, merely acting on instinct as he dove to the side. The insect went flying past, propelled by wings that were previously hidden under it's armored back. Muscles clenched as the human sprang into action. The insect was in the process of turning around when Rebel landed his first blow. He jumped forward, swinging that massive weapon of his as if it were a base-ball bat, letting momentum add force to the blow. The blade collided with the beast's back with such tremendous force that the weapon was jarred clear out of the human's hands, the blade quivering as it fell to the ground. It was as if he had struck a wall of metal. He had no time to retrieve the weapon, barely dodging a swipe of those deadly claws as the bug completed its turn. The thing emitted a clicking hiss at him, it's six legs carrying it forward with surprising speed, arms slashing in a wild attempt to kill its fleshy opponent.

The human was not to be finished off so easily, hopping backwards with each slash of the creature's arms, keeping just out of reach. The creature's back opened up with a buzz again, though this time the short distance prevented the man from fully evading the blow. He rolled to one side, but one of the bug's spines caught his arm and shredded both clothing and flesh as it sped past. Rebel growled in annoyance, ignoring the pain and jumping back to retrieve his sword. Just picking up the heavy blade made his injury hurt all the worse, but he felt better with the worn leather grip in his hands once more.

The bug came whizzing back his direction, legs lifted and wings propelling it through the air like a cannon-ball, head ducked low to impale him on that massive spike. Instead of dodging this time, the human simply held his ground, kneeling down and firmly jamming the hilt of his sword into the dirt at such an angle to brace it against the creature's charge. The bug hit the weapon at full-speed, causing the sword's pommel to bury itself in the dirt. The metal blade bent at a frightening angle... then shattered under the pressure. The impact broke the bug out of it's curl, limbs flailing wildly as it careened into the stubborn man on the other side of the sword.

Rebel gave a grunt as the metal shards of his broken sword pierced into his body, but it was cut short as the giant insect collided with him. That contact sent both man and bug rolling haphazardly across the ground. Rebel's momentum was halted by a small tree, whereas the bug's spines ripped up dirt and grass until it also came to a halt. The human pulled himself to his feet with some great effort, his body sliced and bruised in a hundred different places. Dagger was pulled from his boot, advancing on the prone insect, poised to strike at a moment's notice. As he approached the prone beast he took pause, then lowered his arms. The beast lay with the upper portion of his sword sticking from it's body, viscous black slime seeping form the would. It lay unmoving, save the faint twitch of one of it's legs. The human stood there a moment longer, then shoved the small dagger back into his boot. Blood dripped from the fingers of his injured arm, expression stern as he scowled at the dead creature. "Always hated bugs."
Captain of the Stormrider

Offline Asia Kali Yusufzai

  • Unique Unicorn
  • **********
  • awards This user has been a forum member for over 10 years Top 100 Poster Top 50 Topic Starter This user has donated to the forum.
  • Posts: 2742
  • Gender: Male
    • Steam
    • Fur Affinity
    • DeviantArt
    • Awards
  • Species: Rabbit
  • Coloring: Hot Pink
  • Height: 5'9
  • Weight: 9 stone
  • Build: GORGEOUS
  • Reference: [link]
Re: Writing sample
« Reply #1 on: August 09, 2010, 02:51:32 PM »
You're good at this, a lot better than most that i read... but I am the person who gives critiques to every piece of writing... or atleast almost every piece of writing, on this forum... so here's my critique (and remember, you're a better than most I read, and you're better some people I know who are doing a creative writing degree right now, but there are issues that you can totally fix.)

Quote
the massive man's entire body tensing as he saw the creature that came lumbering from the treeline. In an instant, his massive sword
massive man as a term sounds a bit too silly, due to the alliteration, also, you shouldn't use the same word in two consecutive sentences. Massive is used twice here. massive man with his massive sword.

Quote
his massive sword was in his hands the chipped and battle-worn blade
punctuation between 'hands' and 'the'

Quote
The creature halted, giving the human a good look at it's insect-like body.
why did it halt?

Quote
The creature was one not native to his world, that was for certain. It stood on six spindly legs, each one curling to a sharpened point, all of which were currently embedded in the earth to support the bug's weight. It's body was like that of a beetle standing upright, a mix of mottled brown and black chitin covering it's entirely. Where the plates of that natural armor ended, wicked spines sprouted from it's body. Two limbs were poised in front of the creature, each tipped with three long, blade-like fingers. Four beady eyes stared back at the man, expressionless and black as night. A blunt horn crested the creature's head, which now slowly lowered to aim at the man who stood in its way. The plates on the creatures back opened up with a high-pitched buzzing.
That's a lot of description. Probably too much, especially with the rather list-like way of talking about the the different features and how many of that feature there are. Six spindly legs, two limbs poised, three long fingers, four beady eyes. Just pull it back, and just mention two or three things about it. You want to be focusing on what you want the reader to feel when reading about this creature, not what it precisely looks like. Also, "black as night" is a big cliché

Quote
Rebel did not pause to think, merely acting on instinct as he dove to the side.
maybe a tad too many words for such an active and quick action... Merely is certainly one to cut.

Quote
The insect went flying past, propelled by wings that were previously hidden under it's armored back.
no need to tell people where the wings came from. they can already expect it from the high pitched buzzing of the previous paragraph.

Quote
The insect was in the process of turning around
in the process of turning around? doesn't sound exciting.

Quote
The insect was in the process of turning around when Rebel landed his first blow
also I'm assuming this is talking about the blow that is going to be explained in the next few sentences? The reader should be riding right alongside the action, not being told abuot it after the fact.

Quote
He jumped forward, swinging that massive weapon of his as if it were a base-ball bat, letting momentum add force to the blow
unless there's some modern twist here, is there a need for the baseball bat analogy? also, the momentum thing does not need to be said.

Quote
The blade collided with the beast's back with such tremendous force that the weapon was jarred clear out of the human's hands, the blade quivering as it fell to the ground. It was as if he had struck a wall of metal.
again, not much speed in terms of the feel of the battle. I mean, you could easily say that in a much shorter way. Like this:
Quote
The blade clashed against the armoured beast, shuddering from the impact, falling from Rebel's hands. The beast wasn't even scratched.

Quote
those deadly claws
those is quite a soft and friendly word. and we already know that they're deadly.

Quote
as the bug completed its turn
absolutely no need for this

Quote
The thing
after calling it the creature and the insect so many times... the thing seems kinda off.

Quote
emitted a clicking hiss at him
you could just say
Quote
The beast clicked and hissed

Quote
it's six legs carrying it forward with surprising speed, arms slashing in a wild attempt to kill its fleshy opponent.
There's something wrong with this... either it's the "surprising speed" when other better words are available, like vicious or "it tore up the earth, charging towards him." Maybe it's the "wild attempt." there's something abotu the word "attempt" that makes it seem so ineffectual. Though probably the one that sticks out the most is "fleshy opponent." This lowers the hero onto the same level as the monster. A faceless entity.

Quote
The human
What's with all this "the human, the human, the human," stuff. he's your main character, keep hold of his personality.

There are some other issues at this point but I would just be repeating myself

Quote
Rebel growled in annoyance
annoyance? really? this a fight that he's losing. a fight to the death, and he's a bit miffed?
Quote
Blood dripped from the fingers of his injured arm, expression stern as he scowled at the dead creature. "Always hated bugs."
oh well if he's that kind of character, then maybe Conan here does merely get annoyed in such situations.

Quote
The human pulled himself to his feet with some great effort
don't just say it took great effort. Show it in the guy's actions and voice.



Your main problems are:

I know this sounds weird for prose, but you use too many words for regular sentences.
There's very little sense of fast paced momentum.
You have a very visual sensibility, but that doesnt translate through your prose at the moment.

But the good things are that your visual sense is very strong. You know what looks good, you just gotta make it sound right. Give the feeling of intense action and horrifying sights, not just the explanation of them.

But yeah, this is pretty good.
"Parents always think kids are wasting their youth, and always have done [so] down through the millennia," says Tom Forsyth of RAD Game Tools. "'That Ug, always holding things. His front paws will develop in funny ways. Why can't he walk on all fours like normal proto-hominids?' And so, whatever the kids spend the most time doing, that's always what parents think is a waste of time, and what is corrupting their lives. It doesn't matter what that is. If all they did was homework, parents would be worrying that their kids aren't becoming well-rounded people. And, in fact, parents do this - enrolling math nerds in karate classes and the like. There is no way to win - parental paranoia ensures that kids are always doing the wrong thing."


Puncia's Foundraising Project

 

Powered by EzPortal