American Sniper: 5.7/10
War movies can do one of two things, they can either be awesome action romps with drama and dramatic scenes or they can be powerful political messages about the impact of war, American Sniper attempts to do both and spectacularly fails on both fronts. So lets do the rest of the review portraying each side of a war movie and describing how American sniper does such a poor job in conveying it.
1. The Action side of war:
American Snipers action was, quite frankly, boring. There was one scene, near the beginning of a movie, where the protagonist sniper (who is based on a real person) has to decide whether to shoot a kid or not, that was very dramatic and quite powerful. After that scene you see basically an hour of the sniper shooting people, no significant gore or impact, no good or realistic sound effects, not even really good camera work, it's just one guy shooting and another guy falling down, for the rest of the movie. Action either needs to be ridiculously over the top with gore and explosions and chaos (like Rambo) or tense, dramatic and scary (like Hurtlocker) and American sniper does neither. The movie just becomes a ridiculous shooting gallery with almost no impact of the bullets or anything, I found myself almost falling asleep through some of the action scenes because they just felt that generic. I didn't feel excited about explosions, nor did I feel tense and on the edge of my seat, its action was just boring.
2. The Horror side of war:
American sniper is not like Generation kill, Full metal Jacket or Apocalypse now, it is not about the horrors of war. The movie is summed up with one line near the beginning, "There are sheeps, who are naive and vulnerable, there are wolves who attack the sheep and there are sheep dogs who protect the sheep from the wolves". Well in this movie, EVERY iraqi is a wolf, they are all TERRORISTS and they all SHOULD BE STOPPED. So in comes our sheep dog, the American sniper, to stop all the evil muslims from destroying our sheep, but who are the sheep? The sheep is us, the people who question the war, even if they're soldiers fighting in the war, if you're unsure whether violence is the answer, WELL it looks like your a vulnerable, naive sheep and need to be protected by the sheep-dog from all the terrorists. That's the message this movie is trying to convey, it's a terrible message that basically believes in a black and white world where "IRAQIS ARE EVIL AND AMERICANS ARE GOOD, AND IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE US YOU'RE A NAIVE SHEEP WHO NEEDS PROTECTING". Seriously, if you're wondering whether this movie will have any sort of moral ambiguity in it, it doesn't, even that one scene where the kid is killed, it is showed explicitly and very matter-of-factly that if the kid wasn't killed than he would of killed all the marines, it would of been better if he had to struggle with that decision. What's even more insulting is how they MAKE UP STUFF about the Iraq war to make it more sympathetic to the American side, like that 9/11 was the reason the Iraq war was initiated, NOT threats of WMDs.
I really didn't like the movie, it was boring and way too "MURRICA" for me.