now now, disparaging someone's writing especially when it's utterly improvised without any real chance to rewrite doesn't really help much.
Also it's my personal opinion that gory visuals does not equal horror. It's like Dead Space. It's all loud and shouty with blood and guts and splashy squishiness and things running around with their arms in the air going "BE AFRAID! BE AFRAAAAAAIIID!" accompanied by wiggly fingered spooky jazz hands; simply because it doesn't know how to scare people, so it shoves it all in your face
An old man smiling at you from across a park can be scarier... if it's done right.
Fear is a feeling after all, so you gotta make it feel right, not look right or sound right, but FEEL right.
So in my opinion both you and Entaru are doing it wrong
but then as with all opinions, it's all absurdly subjective and nobody's got the right answer.