11
Titan II
The Saturn V had a much lower thrust-to-weight ratio than Project Gemini's Titan II GLV. Richard F. Gordon, Jr. described Saturn as "an old man's ride", with "a lot more shake-rattle-and-roll" but milder thrust. Buzz Aldrin and other Apollo 11 astronauts agreed that they could not tell when Saturn liftoff occurred except from instruments, unlike on Titan.[26]
Soviet N1-L3
A comparison of the U.S. Saturn V rocket with the Soviet N1-L3
The Soviet space program's counterpart to the Saturn V was Sergei Korolev's N1-L3. The Saturn V was taller, heavier, and had greater payload capacity, both to low Earth orbit and to translunar injection.[27] The N-1 was a three-stage launch vehicle with more liftoff thrust and a larger first stage diameter than the Saturn V.[28] It was to carry the 209,000 lb (95,000 kg) L3 vehicle into orbit. The L3 contained an Earth departure stage, which would send to the Moon a 51,800 lb (23,500 kg) package which contained another stage for lunar orbit insertion and powered descent initiation, a single-cosmonaut lander, and a two-cosmonaut lunar orbiter for the return to Earth. The N1/L3 would have produced more total impulse (product of thrust and time) in its first four stages than the three-stage Saturn V, but it was not able to convert as much of this into payload momentum (product of mass and velocity).
The N1 never became operational; four test launches each resulted in catastrophic vehicle failure early in flight, and the program was canceled. Korolev elected to cluster 30 relatively small engines for the first stage, rather than develop a large engine like the Rocketdyne F-1.
The three-stage Saturn V grew over its lifetime to a peak thrust of at least 7,650,000 lbf (34,020 kN) (AS-510 and subsequent)[29] and a lift capacity of 310,000 lb (140,000 kg) to LEO. The AS-510 mission (Apollo 15) had a liftoff thrust of 7,823,000 lbf (34,800 kN). The AS-513 mission (Skylab 1) had slightly greater liftoff thrust of 7,891,000 lbf (35,100 kN). By comparison, the N-1 had a sea-level liftoff thrust of about 10,200,000 lbf (45,400 kN).[30] No other operational launch vehicle has ever surpassed the Saturn V in height, weight, total impulse, or payload capability. The closest contenders were the US Space Shuttle and the Soviet Energia.
Saturn V (Apollo 11)[31] N1-L3
Diameter, maximum 33 ft (10 m) 56 ft (17 m)
Height w/ payload 363 ft (111 m) 344 ft (105 m)
Gross weight 6,478,000 lb (2,938 t) 6,030,000 lb (2,735 t)
First stage S-IC Block A
Thrust, SL 7,500,000 lbf (33,000 kN) 10,200,000 lbf (45,400 kN)
Burn time, s 168 125
Second stage S-II Block B
Thrust, vac 1,155,800 lbf (5,141 kN) 3,160,000 lbf (14,040 kN)
Burn time, s 384 120
Orbital insertion stage S-IVB (burn 1) Block V
Thrust, vac 202,600 lbf (901 kN) 360,000 lbf (1,610 kN)
Burn time, s 147 370
Total impulse[32] 1.7336×109 lbf (7.711×106 kN)·s 1.789×109 lbf (7.956×106 kN)·s
Orbital payload 264,900 lb (120.2 t)[33] 209,000 lb (95 t)
Injection velocity 25,568 ft/s (7,793 m/s) 25,570 ft/s (7,793 m/s)[34]
Payload momentum 2.105×108 slug-ft/s (9.363×108 kg·m/s) 1.6644×108 slug-ft/s (7.403×108 kg·m/s)
Propulsive efficiency 12.14% 9.31%
Earth departure stage S-IVB (burn 2) Block G
Thrust, vac 201,100 lbf (895 kN) 100,000 lbf (446 kN)
Burn time, s 347 443
Total impulse[32] 1.8034×109 lbf (8.022×106 kN)·s 1.833×109 lbf (8.153×106 kN)·s
Translunar payload 100,740 lb (45.69 t) 52,000 lb (23.5 t)
Injection velocity 35,545 ft/s (10,834 m/s) 35,540 ft/s (10,834 m/s)[34]
Payload momentum 1.1129×108 slug-ft/s (4.95×108 kg·m/s) 5.724×107 slug-ft/s (2.546×108 kg·m/s)
Propulsive efficiency 6.17% 3.12%